2005 AR230HO worth?

[DaveShip55]

Kind of a strange question, what do ya think a 2005 AR230HO would be worth, with one of the engines blown. From what I can tell, looks like the #1 cylinder has a broken rod. (Starboard Engine). The Port engine runs great.
The boat itself is GREAT condition, interior is in perfect condition. Also has a great stereo system, 3 XS Power Batteries, 12 Polk speakers, two 12“ Alpine subs, 5 Amps.
I’m guessing from the little research I’ve done, looks like a ‘rebuilt’ long block would cost around $5000..... but might be a great deal for someone that wants to replace an engine and have a nice boat,
Thanks in advance for any input,
-Dave

 

[Dixie Highway]

I'll give ya $50...seriously though no clue. This is one of those "it's worth what someone will give you" questions, most people would find the cost of replacing an engine more than the boat's value. Now, someone that does work themselves would make it worth their while.

 

[DaveShip55]

Kind of a strange question, what do ya think a 2005 AR230HO would be worth, with one of the engines blown. From what I can tell, looks like the #1 cylinder has a broken rod. (Starboard Engine). The Port engine runs great.
The boat itself is GREAT condition, interior is in perfect condition. Also has a great stereo system, 3 XS Power Batteries, 12 Polk speakers, two 12“ Alpine subs, 5 Amps.
I’m guessing from the little research I’ve done, looks like a ‘rebuilt’ long block would cost around $5000..... but might be a great deal for someone that wants to replace an engine and have a nice boat,
Thanks in advance for any input,
-Dave

ADMIN - MOVED THIS POST HERE FROM A DUPLICATE THREAD

 

[Julian]

Kind of a strange question, what do ya think a 2005 AR230HO would be worth, with one of the engines blown. From what I can tell, looks like the #1 cylinder has a broken rod. (Starboard Engine). The Port engine runs great.
The boat itself is GREAT condition, interior is in perfect condition. Also has a great stereo system, 3 XS Power Batteries, 12 Polk speakers, two 12“ Alpine subs, 5 Amps.
I’m guessing from the little research I’ve done, looks like a ‘rebuilt’ long block would cost around $5000..... but might be a great deal for someone that wants to replace an engine and have a nice boat,
Thanks in advance for any input,
-Dave

Here is the NADA value:


You can find the link to this in the FAQ

So with a blown engine....8-10k? Depends on just how nice shape it is in. You'd likely be better off replacing the engine and then selling it....but that is a lot of work.

 

[DaveShip55]

Here is the NADA value:
View attachment 126834

You can find the link to this in the FAQ

So with a blown engine....8-10k? Depends on just how nice shape it is in. You'd likely be better off replacing the engine and then selling it....but that is a lot of work.

Thanks,.... that’s my dilemma, really don’t want to put the work into replacing the motor.... just kinda want to get whatever I can get out of it, then buy a new one.... must admit, it’s been a GREAT boat for 16 years, I’ve changed the oil and plugs every year. Not sure what caused the engine failure. A couple weeks ago the engine got REAL HOT,... I think something maybe plugged the intake.... would barely run afterwards, limped back to the marina on one engine, checked the plugs, two were completely melted away.... put new plugs in it, and it ran perfectly!... Then this weekend after a few days on the lake, the same engine died completely, checked the plugs again, and the one in #1 cylinder, the plug tab was smashed into the electrode. Put a scope camera down in the cylinder and the piston isn’t moving when turning the motor over.

 

[Beachbummer]

How little are you willing to take? It will require a significant time investment. If you are willing to take $7K or $8K someone might take it from you. Worst case, eBay.

 

[the MfM]

A dealer would charge ~$15k to replace an engine. So I’d say based on blue book $50 is pretty generous

 

[tdonoughue]

Got insurance? Might not be covered, but would be worth making a claim... Maybe they would total it--problem solved.

 

[Ronnie]

Used yamaha jet boats are hard to come by right now, especially during the pandemic. If the boat was running I’m sure that you could easily get $20k for it. If it were me, I’d buy a used waverunner with the same engine and sell the boat with waverunner engine and without the broken one “as is” uninstalled. Another option is replace the engine with one rebuilt by sbt. Someone here just did so for around $3,500 but he did all the labor so the actual cost is probably closer to $5k,
$400 less if you go with the 1 year warranty instead of 2 year.

If I were a potential buyer I would not pay more than $10k for it knowing that a used waverunner will cost me around $5k, assuming I could get one at all. Good used pwcs are hard to find right now as well.

 

[dyfanf]

where are you/the boat located?

 

[DaveShip55]

Thanks for all the advice everyone!.... yeah, here in SoCal and AZ area, these boats in good running order are going for around $20k... and mines in immaculate condition, other than the blown motor...LoL!... I have the boat stored at an indoor storage in Lake Havasu.
You have no idea how bummed I am about this, this boat has been my baby, and I’ve taken such good care of her, then this happened.... uuggggg!... After agonizing over this, I kinda really want to get rid of it, getting the most I can... obviously..lol
Our plan is to retire in about 5 years, so my plan was to sell this one eventually anyways, but I wasn’t planning on an engine blowing up.... uuuggg,
But the plan was to buy a new Yamaha and enjoy retirement. I guess I’ll advertise it and see what I can get? $10k might be a good starting point.... someone with the time and skills could have beautiful boat for under $20k
Wonder if dealerships would take it as a trade in?.... if they did, prolly only get the previously offered $50..... HaHaHa

 

[Beachbummer]

Be careful for what you wish. For the cost difference, investing a little time in repairing your boat, it will likely be as reliable as anything else you can buy from Yamaha today. If you plan was a dual outboard boat I'd tell you to sell so you can swap, but for the cost difference you won't get your money's worth in another jet boat. Find someone local to rebuild your engine and put it back together, you might find keeping it, and the cash, is the best option.

Best of Luck however you proceed!

 

[cybuch]

how many hours on it?

 

[DaveShip55]

I honestly don’t know how many hours I have on it... but if I were to guess, probably about 500.

 

[the MfM]

Thanks for all the advice everyone!.... yeah, here in SoCal and AZ area, these boats in good running order are going for around $20k... and mines in immaculate condition, other than the blown motor...LoL!... I have the boat stored at an indoor storage in Lake Havasu.
You have no idea how bummed I am about this, this boat has been my baby, and I’ve taken such good care of her, then this happened.... uuggggg!... After agonizing over this, I kinda really want to get rid of it, getting the most I can... obviously..lol
Our plan is to retire in about 5 years, so my plan was to sell this one eventually anyways, but I wasn’t planning on an engine blowing up.... uuuggg,
But the plan was to buy a new Yamaha and enjoy retirement. I guess I’ll advertise it and see what I can get? $10k might be a good starting point.... someone with the time and skills could have beautiful boat for under $20k
Wonder if dealerships would take it as a trade in?.... if they did, prolly only get the previously offered $50..... HaHaHa

Start asking around for the names of mechanics or small shops that work on jet skis. There’s got to be quite a few in your area. They’ll likely either be able to install an SBT engine reasonably or have a spare engine/crashed ski nearby. Heck, I have one in my barn that I’m saving for when I find a boat that just needs an engine.

 

[tdonoughue]

Might want to try a dealer. If you are looking for a new boat, see what you will get for a trade. Can't hurt, and you may be surprised. They may just give you the $10k these days and invest in putting in the engine. They know in this market they can sell it fast...

 

[DaveShip55]

Thanks, that was my backup plan, but I thought I’d give selling at a try. Put it up for sale Friday night, and my phone was blowing up,,, Sold it sight unseen for $11,000. Probably should have put it in for more, LoL... but the buyer is getting a great boat, it’s in excellent condition other than the one motor. Heck, he could rebuild or replace the motor...and sell it for $20k plus... I’ve seen some in my area going for $24k (boat prices are crazy around here,)... and I can almost guarantee they’re not as nice as mine. Literally the interior looks brand new..... then throw in the stereo... which I’m guessing I have close to $7k to $8k.... (dang, stereo stuff adds up quickly, even doing it yourself!”
Now it’s time to start thinking about a new boat,.... really like the AR242X.... but I can’t find one anywhere, might have to wait for the 2021’s. Any early rumors on the 2021’s...... HaHaHa HaHaHa But definitely gonna go with another Yamaha.... this past boat was absolutely problem free for 16 years!!!!!!!!

 

[itsdgm]

Congrats on the sale. I’m in so cal too. I’ve pulled an engine in my boat and replaced it for under $2k with a waverunner engine. At the time there were several used low hour engines out there. Not sure about now though.

Anyway, good luck with your next boat On to bigger and better things. ????Not your problem now. ?

 

[OCMD]

And whatever you do, do not buy a replacement engine from the aforementioned manufacturuer. Speaking from experience and vast knowledge of similarly situated folks who purchased those engines over the years. The warranty is crap also. The engine will fail, but they usually go just long enough to get you out of the warranty period. They'll sell you 2 year warranty based on the crap they put in 'em to last 2 and a half years. One year warranty? It will last one and a half years. And the warranty won't cover removal and installation. They bank on the fact that most of the country uses their boat during the summer, and if lucky, put 50 hours on 'em. When you go out the next season, and start putting the additonal hours 50-100 on 'em, they fail and the year in time is up. Get an engine off a used jet ski and fix 'er up! You will be good to go. To make matters worse, you can't sue'em as they have a binding arbitration clause in the warranty. (That is, unless you have a shark such as myself who can twist out of that mandatory clause, lol) Contrary to popular mistaken belief, arbitration is MUCH more expensive to the consumer, than proceeding with a lawsuit. So basically, the consumer is screwed because they think they can't sue. But it won't fail until out of warranty, so I guess it doesn't matter anyway lol.

 

[DaveShip55]

I sold it, not sure what the new owner plans on doing, but I’ll let him know about the SBT engines. Wonder why they are crap. Substandard parts.
Speaking of engines.... I apologize, I’ve been off the forums for a while now.... a long while, LoL.... but how are the 1.8 liters. I’ve been trying to catch up, going thru the posts..... haven’t seen much negative comments regarding the 1.8’s. As of now my plan is a new AR242X.... but no telling if they’ll even have this model next year....