FWIW,
My friend who was helping me decide which boat to buy has this mantra, “The smallest size that will get the job done”.
That being said, he was pushing for the 19’ model FSH as I was going to be doing the majority of my boating by myself. My argument was that I wanted to be able to take friends out and the bow seating was needed for that, not to mention the under seat storage. To be fair, it looks like the 19’ model has some good storage up front, but that forward seat faces the stern. After fishing off the boat my friend said that he was glad I insisted on the 21’ FSH as the layout of the bow made it much better for fishing and cruising. Two people can lounge up front while underway, or I’ve had four sitting up there when we made the hour and a half ride down to rainbow bridge at Lake Powell, during that particular journey there was another person on the forward CC seat and two people in the jump seats, everyone was comfortable on that ride. There were also some other shorter journeys we made, as well as some evening cruises through the canyons. I would have been really limited on space with the 19’ model.
I also added the front casting platform from JBP but I don’t think that is available from them anymore. However I’m sure that could be fabricated by a crafty DIY’er, or a shop could make it for you. I’ve used that platform with cushions as a bed on several occasions, slept there for a week at LP, and a few overnights locally. And it makes into a table which I’ve used a few times.
If your wife likes to lay out, you may want to consider getting the swim step cushions. My friends wife commented once the only thing my boat didn’t do was allow her to layout on her stomach. Unless your wife is 5’ tall she would be able to layout on her stomach on the casting platform.
Back to the garage storage and the T top. The first model FSH boats were 19’ and the top did pivot forward Im pretty sure and I thought of modifying mine to do the same. But, after measuring I found that when folded forward the top portion would still stick up too high to fit in my shop. I have to take off the windshield and fold down my fish finder to get it in the shop.
Ueah the prices have gone up on these boats considerably since 2020, but so has everything else, inflation is being felt across the board. As a good friend of mine used to say “There aren’t any Uhauls following the hearse to the graveyard“.
In the end it comes down to:
What are going to use the boat for?
How often are you going to use the boat?
How many people are going to be on the boat?
Which boat do you really want?
There is always this handy guide.
View attachment 192165