"“If your fighting the wind and current and you miss the approach, you might get pushed into another boater or dock or the shore or you'll have to back out and completely start over”.
NO. "
hear me out.
I'm speaking from my own personal experience and the local ramps that I frequent. Each dock and ramp is subject to is own conditions and situations that you'll eventually learn.
When I was learning to boat, I was 99% of the time alone and handling the approach, dock lines, other boaters, wind, current and everything else was overwhelming at times and still is. I also don't think were talking about 30mph winds with 70mph gusts. lets say for the purpose of a new boater they are likely not going out in anything much higher than 15mph wings(?).
Yes the common approach that is standard when docking is to go against the wind as you will likely have better control. but this only works if you're following all the other procedures leading up to docking.
docking with the wind at your back will get you on the dock one way or another and when I'm solo, that is all I care about in the moment and docking against the wind is going to be up to many more factors involved.
He is talking about going out as a new captain without a crew. is he gonna nail the approach 1st try fighting the wind? likely not as we all see captains with years and years of experience looking like they have no idea what they are doing every day in a slight breeze. there are tons of YouTube channels dedicated to people trying to maneuver in and out of docks and ramps and hundreds of videos of captains smashing into the wrong dock or getting blow into other boats and creating all kinds of issues because they are fighting the wind. I cannot assume that this guy, no offense, will be any better then what we all see in the real world. You've got twin jets, 2 throttles, fwd neutral and reverse and in my experience this is plenty enough for me to control my boat with the wind in any direction (within reason of course).
My crude drawing is more often than not the situations I face at my local ramps. If I take spots 1 or 2 I risk not hitting my mark and getting blow off the dock and shoved into the red or purple boat while I'm tripping over my lines, trying to turn the engines off and find my shoes. Also if I take 1 or 2 my approach and technique has to be more defined and fine tuned. if I take spot 3 I can have a much more sloppy approach and can come from either direction and the wind push me against the dock and give me more time to get the lines tied.
After I gained more experience and learned my boats better ill choose 1 or 2, mainly to keep the wind and current from slamming the boat into the dock wile I retrieve the truck.
View attachment 222663