Buckeye Lake sucks when it's busy. The shallow water makes it ROUGH EVERYWHERE! I mean the entire lake is choppy. Similarly, where GiddYupJoe boats (Indian Lake) gets rough too, but it's a bigger lake and there are more places to hide and get away from the chop, plus its a little deeper overall. Both of those lakes I would be paranoid in without a jet.
@Julian You really can't tell from google earth or maps where the dam is. The houses and everything are really built right on it. I couldn't even begin to tell you how far it runs without looking it up. I am fairly certain it runs from Crane Lake / Crane Island west to Sellers Point.
Here is a pretty good article / video to watch giving some history and nice information
http://www.newarkadvocate.com/videos/news/local/2015/03/20/25025337/
Don't get me wrong, we REALLY like Buckeye Lake. It's just not the family/watersports lake like most of you know and love. It's more adult oriented as there are something like 22 bars on the lake give or take a few but it's over 20. There is only a sandbar to swim at and its a party bar so again not the best for kids. But they love seeing the houses and just site seeing there. Also Cranberry Bog is really cool island you can dock and get on and they think is cool. We don't get there too often but it's always a fun trip AND their fireworks show on the 4th is one of the best I've seen.